Four Black Quarterbacks with Everything to Prove in 2025

The countdown is almost over. The 2025 NFL season is about to hurtle into view, and even before the first snap, the storylines are already stacked sky-high.
The reigning champion Philadelphia Eagles kick off the defence of their title against the ever-dangerous Dallas Cowboys in an intense opening day showdown. Days later, the NFC North takes centre stage as the Packers and Lions reignite one of football’s fiercest modern rivalries. And in the first Sunday primetime game of the season, two AFC powerhouses—the Bills and Ravens, both bruised by recent heartbreaks—collide in a brawl headlined by MVP-caliber quarterbacks Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson.
But amid the swirling storm of league-wide narratives, a new storyteller is set to hit the town in the form of the upstart LuckyRebel.la website. The fledgling outlet’s impending release has set the sports world ablaze, with the site said to be offering an unparalleled selection to punters all across the country. We imagine that these four quarterbacks and their now-or-never stories will certainly feature prominently.
Kyler Murray
For six seasons, Kyler Murray has been an enigma—a force of nature armed with a rocket arm and sprinter’s legs, yet unable to will the Arizona Cardinals beyond mediocrity. His career ledger glitters individually: since 2019, over 18,000 passing yards, more than 110 total touchdowns, and a highlight reel that would make even his harshest critics double-take. But in the light of more postseason failure—just one playoff game in the last six years—the sizzle hasn’t translated to steak.
2024 only amplified the paradox. Murray ripped through September, dealing 12 touchdowns in the year’s first five games and executing a signature 30-yard scramble to seal a crucial divisional win. Yet the promise curdled down the stretch; over the final eight games, his completion percentage crashed to 61%, his passer rating slumped, and the Cardinals lost six of their last eight—a collapse labelled at the very least as a mirror of missed opportunity.
Arizona’s brass acted accordingly, overhauling the supporting cast and entering 2025 with postseason or bust expectations—period. For Murray, this is no longer about raw potential but about results. Can he shed the aura of the nearly man and deliver, or does a new era loom in the desert?
Bryce Young
When the Carolina Panthers made Bryce Young the first overall pick of the 2023 draft, the message was clear: salvation starts under center. That narrative quickly curdled into panic. Young’s rookie season was a waterlogged affair—plagued by a malfunctioning offense, pocket collapses, and accuracy issues that saw his completion percentage dip below 58% for half the year. He was benched, doubted, and—whisper it—considered a possible cautionary tale.
But late in 2024, the tide turned. Thrust back into the fire, Young orchestrated three wins in the final four games, tossing 11 touchdowns to just two interceptions and flashing the out-of-structure creativity that made him a collegiate superstar. The numbers sang, but the critics—never far from the megaphone—inhaled. Was it a fleeting hot streak or proof of substance? With C.J. Stroud, taken one spot behind Young in the 2023 draft and already posting superstar numbers in Houston, the microscope has never been more unforgiving.
Now, entering Year Three, the verdict looms. Analysts project the Panthers as a fringe NFC playoff team—if, and only if, Young can sustain that late 2024 poise. Every throw in Charlotte will echo. For Young and the thousands who see themselves in his journey, 2025 is less a season and more a referendum.
Shedeur Sanders
Some NFL stories defy the numbers. Enter Shedeur Sanders. After a collegiate career where he threw for over 9,000 yards and 73 touchdowns at Colorado, not even his most strident detractor expected him to slide to the fifth round of the 2025 NFL Draft. The immediate response? Disbelief, followed by heated debate about enduring, often-unspoken biases in evaluating Black quarterbacks—a conversation as old as the league itself.
But Shedeur is no stranger to adversity. He drops into Cleveland’s overcrowded quarterback room—one where Deshaun Watson’s health, Joe Flacco’s twilight, and Kenny Pickett’s inconsistency are sure to keep the depth chart in constant flux. Factor in rookie Dillon Gabriel and a howling Cleveland media, and the challenge seems Herculean.
Yet, early flashes have turned heads and quieted doubters. Insiders highlight Sanders’ surgical accuracy and unshakeable maturity in the pocket during pre-season work, outshining even more experienced peers. Still, camp heroics are a mere appetizer—the real test arrives when the live bullets fly in autumn. A fifth-round tag sticks until you rip it off. Should Sanders earn meaningful snaps—or the starting gig—his journey won’t just change the Browns’ season, it will change the franchise’s entire immediate future.
Geno Smith
It is a cruel fact of pro football that some careers—even the most remarkable comebacks—are shadowed by doubt. Geno Smith, the NFL’s eternal survivor, re-established himself in Seattle last season, posting a career-best 4,320 yards while leading the Seahawks to a respectable 19-7 record. His QBR soared above 93, his completion rate cleared 70%, and he even broke franchise passing records once thought untouchable.
But even in a career year, there was some regression. Smith’s touchdown rate plummeted, mistakes inside the red zone – an abysmal 5 INTs in the final six games – spooked Seahawks fans and torpedoed momentum. Entering his 12th pro campaign, Smith now starts anew with the Las Vegas Raiders, under the familiar command of Pete Carroll. The mission? Reverse a generational culture of losing and guide a talent-short roster through the AFC West gauntlet.
Smith’s margin for error is threadbare. One more downturn, and the whispers of decline may become roars. But a resurgence—leveraging experience, grit, and Carroll’s trust—could cement his place as one of the league’s most respected statesmen and, more significantly, as a beacon for perseverance in a league quick to count out Black quarterbacks before their stories are finished.